Welcome to Mcgill's Whiskey Tavern and Grill
Mcgill's Whiskey Tavern and Grill, located in Utica, NY, is a hidden gem renowned for its inviting atmosphere and mouthwatering offerings. This local favorite combines a warm tavern vibe with an impressive menu featuring enormous portion sizes that delight patrons. Diners rave about standout dishes such as the bacon blue burger, lobster mac and cheese, and crispy chicken riggies; each plate bursts with flavor and generous ingredients. With friendly service and budget-friendly prices, Mcgill's ensures a memorable dining experience, making it a must-visit spot for food lovers and families alike. It's a true testament to the quality of local dining.
-
2284 NY-5, Utica, NY 13502, United States Hotline: +1 315-507-2512
Welcome to Mcgill's Whiskey Tavern and Grill, a hidden gem nestled in Utica, NY. Located at 2284 NY-5, this tavern is more than just a place to grab a bite; it's an experience that combines the warmth of a local pub with a culinary adventure that keeps patrons coming back for more.
As soon as you step inside, you're greeted by a cozy, low-key atmosphere that encourages relaxation and enjoyment. The charm is palpable, thanks in part to the welcoming service provided by owner Darla and her attentive staff. It's not just about the food here; it’s the sense of community and hospitality that elevates your visit.
The menu at Mcgill's is a delightful assortment of comfort food that will tantalize your taste buds. Diners rave about the bacon blue burger, which has garnered enthusiastic praise for its flavors and juiciness. And let’s not overlook the chicken bacon ranch mac and cheese, a crowd favorite that is as indulgent as it sounds, bursting with creamy goodness and topped with crispy bacon. It’s dishes like these that earn accolades like "fricking amazing" from satisfied customers.
For seafood lovers, the lobster mac and cheese is a must-try. Diners have claimed it to be life-changing, with large chunks of succulent lobster swimming in a rich, creamy sauce—a true testament to Mcgill's dedication to quality ingredients. Don’t miss their crispy fried pickles either, expertly breaded to perfection with a delightful crunch, steering clear of that soggy texture many places struggle with.
Wings enthusiasts will also find their sanctuary here. The chicken riggies and buffalo chicken options are particularly noteworthy, combining hearty flavors with ample portion sizes. Customers consistently note that the portions at Mcgill's are nothing short of enormous—the ideal indulgence after a long day or a casual night out with friends.
What’s more, Mcgill's Whiskey Tavern and Grill values affordability without compromising on quality. Patrons often express surprise at the generous serving sizes relative to the prices, making it a fantastic spot for those looking to enjoy hearty meals without breaking the bank. It’s a place where locals love to gather over cold brews and delicious bites, echoing sentiments of supportive community spirit.
In summary, Mcgill's Whiskey Tavern and Grill is not just a restaurant; it's a culinary haven brimming with friendly service and appetizing food that leaves a lasting impression. Whether you’re in for a casual dinner or a special occasion, make sure to stop by this local favorite for an exhilarating dining experience that you won't soon forget.
What a great little spot. A friend took me here and wow! Had the bacon blue burger and it was fricking amazing. We also ordered a bowl of chicken bacon ranch mac and cheese, yeah that's right, once again fricking amazing. So much food for a great price. Definitely going to stop back on Wednesday for the Mac and cheese specials. The service topped it off, our waitress was friendly, jovial and just cool.
My wife and I are now life time fans. Service was good, but the food was out of this world. Prices were so cheap in comparison to the portion sizes, and the food itself was mouth watering/life changing. The lobster mac and cheese had massive chunks of lobster and each bite was creamy and saucy (i.e NOT dry like most). The fried pickles spears were stellar, perfectly breaded with none of the soggy greasy texture that many places have. My long island was poured with a HEAVY hand and made me a very happy lady. My friend ordered the steak and greens sub and swears she will be eating it for days, if not until the new year .
Went to visit a friend for the weekend in the area and knowing I enjoy a tavern/ low key type atmosphere, she brought me here. It was extremely warm and welcoming and Darla, the owner, sat us. She provided 10/10 service and 10/10 conversation. We got an order of 10 wings, crispy, and a creamy western sauce. We also order Mac n cheese with pulled pork and mac n cheese with buffalo chicken. All I can say is W O W. All the food is fresh, flavorful, and the portions are generous. 20/10 recommend stopping by
Love to support locals and this is a local favorite... Nothing like a couple cold brews and some hot food! The wings are great, mac and cheese is awesome, burgers, Philly cheesesteak, pulled pork sandwich is huge and nice chicken riggies, really good! Stop in you'll see what I mean. A friendly welcoming place! Oh see Erin at the bar, so nice, efficient and pleasant! We'll be back.
Huge portions and I mean huge. Service is very friendly and prompt. Chicken riggies are very flavorful and did I say the portions are huge. Lobster Mac was incredible along with the well cooked and flavored burger. Garlic bread was huge also and actually flavored. This is a great place to eat.
Huge portions! Food was all fantastic and we had plenty to bring home. We went for the boneless chicken wing special for my son but didn’t realize it was for the bar only. I didn’t let this effect my rating but they should allow tables the bar special with an alcoholic beverage order if they have small children. We will be going back for wing night!
Angie the server helped me feel right at home. She was fast, courteous, and an overall pleasure to be around. I had some questions about the menu and not only was she attentive to my needs, also she was very informative. The food presentation was impeccable and the portions were huge. I was able to bring a box home and eat it for lunch. Ask for Angie when you go to Mcgills you will not be disappointed, that woman can read your mind. Mcgills is a hidden gem in Oneida County area. I’ll be back very soon!
McGill's is my go-to place for riggies! I love that you can order chicken, sausage, meatball, or lobster riggies. The prices are fantastic and the portion sizes are ENORMOUS. Whenever I buy a full order of riggies to go, it's enough for 5-6 meals. Also, their friday fish fry is top notch! Sides that are included with the already huge portions of the entrees are similarly large. Don't sleep on their macaroni salad -- it's amazing!